
Written by: Meredith Garriott, L’28
For years, the mostly senior residents of Legacy at Imperial Village, an affordable apartment complex in Richmond, have faced repeated hazardous living conditions such as pest infestations, broken elevators, and unreliable HVAC systems with little accountability from the landlord or government.[1] Despite 180 city code enforcement cases against the New Jersey-based LLC that acquired the property in 2021, residents of Legacy at Imperial Village continued to deal with ongoing health and safety issues with no recourse.[2] Many of those city code enforcement cases resulted in violations for which the city threatened fines, but never imposed.[3] Elderly and disabled residents faced greater health and financial challenges as a result of the landlords failure to address necessary maintenance issues, a pattern that can be seen repeated across the nation.[4]
From frustratingly long wait times for the only working elevator in a building that mainly houses senior residents with mobility issues, to a resident on oxygen having to purchase his own AC unit in order to ensure he had a consistent flow of cool air, residents felt repeatedly failed by their landlord who continued to demand rent money while refusing to provide the proper living conditions tenants were promised when they signed their lease.[5] It was not until a news article detailing how neither the landlord nor city officials have properly addressed the deplorable conditions for years that the City finally took visible action.[6] However, such action has yet to result in any meaningful remedy for the residents who felt forced to endure bad living conditions because the lack of affordable housing options made the already expensive act of moving impossible.[7]
This situation is not unique to the residents of Legacy at Imperial Village in Richmond, but rather a pervasive issue across Virginia in which vulnerable renters are left with few legal protections from neglectful landlords. In fact, only a little over an hour’s drive away from Legacy at Imperial Village sits another apartment complex where residents have been facing similar issues. The residents of Park’s Edge, a Charlottesville apartment complex that receives low-income housing tax credits (LIHTC), have dealt with ongoing health and safety hazards since 2020 when an LLC acquired the property.[8] Leaking sewage, floods, rat infestations, mold, sparking electrical outlets, faulty appliances, and broken smoke detectors are among only some of the issues residents faced while pleas to the landlord for help went unanswered.[9]
Nationwide, low-income renters are more likely to live in worse conditions than renters with higher incomes.[10] Housing quality issues such as mold, pest infestations, and inadequate plumbing or HVAC systems often result in greater health risks such as asthma and respiratory illnesses as well as more emotional and behavioral challenges in children, all of which impose greater financial costs on the already financially burdened renter.[11]
While Virginia Code § 55.1-1220 requires landlords to maintain fit and habitable living conditions for all tenants, many low-income renters in Virginia are left with little practical options when faced with landlords who fail to meet this requirement.[12] The tenant remedies provided by the Virginia Residential Landlord and Tenant Act (VRLTA) are minimal and often not accessible to low-income renters who are unable to afford private legal counsel or access the overburdened legal aid system.[13] Of the remedies offered by the VRLTA, requiring the landlord to fix the maintenance issue in question is not one of them.[14] Instead, some of the only options tenants have in response to a landlord who fails to meet the minimum requirements are to terminate the lease and move out,[15] file a tenant’s assertion and sue for damages while continuing to pay rent into an escrow account,[16] or repair the issue themselves and later receive limited compensation[17]— all costly options which low-income renters often cannot afford, leaving them with no access to justice.
Just as the residents of Legacy at Imperial Village and Park’s Edge felt forced to live in poor conditions because the expense made moving impossible, many low-income renters find the VRLTA’s option to terminate the lease due to a landlord’s noncompliance an option that is out of reach. A key factor that makes moving so out of reach for low-income renters is the lack of affordable housing across Virginia. For every 100 extremely low-income households in the commonwealth there are only 35 affordable rental homes available.[18] To compound on this, seniors and people with disabilities make up a large majority of extremely low-income households.[19]
Low-income renters also find the VRLTA’s option to sue for damages a difficult remedy to obtain.[20] Legal representation is expensive and those who qualify for legal aid may not be able to receive needed assistance due to the overburdened system.[21] Even with legal counsel, renters are greatly limited by the VRLTA regarding what kinds of damages they may receive. For example, in Isbell v. Commercial Investment Associates, the Virginia Supreme Court held that tenants cannot recover for personal injury in tort where the landlord violated the VRLTA.[22]
As more attention is brought to the lack of legal protections for vulnerable renters in Virginia, there is hope that positive change is on the horizon. Some local governments across the commonwealth have begun implementing rental inspection programs as a way to ensure suitable living conditions for tenants.[23] So far, at least 18 of these programs exist across Virginia, with more counties considering or already in the process of creating such programs including the City of Richmond.[24] The cost of government run rental inspection programs as well as opposition from local landlords can deter localities from implementing them.[25] There is also a concern that rental inspection programs can lead to unintended consequences for the renters such as displacement. A remedy for displacement concerns could be relocation assistance programs.[26] Because rental inspection programs are limited in what they can do, Virginia renters would benefit from the addition of greater protections and avenues of recourse under the VRLTA.
Some recently and soon-to-be enacted Virginia laws take steps towards providing these much needed tenant protections. One such change allows local governments to sue non-complying landlords for injunction and damages on behalf of the tenants.[27] This greatly expands the ability for low-income tenants to hold negligent landlords accountable, however, they still must rely on their locality’s prosecutor to take the case, which is never guaranteed.[28] Another new protection for tenants allows tenants to raise a landlord’s noncompliance as a defense to an eviction, a defense that was surprisingly not priorly available.[29] In finding for the tenant, a judge may order the landlord to fix the issue at hand, among other remedies.[30]
There is still much more room for Virginia to grow when it comes to expanding tenant protections. One avenue that could expand low-income renters ability to receive justice are class-action lawsuits. Virginia is one of only two states in the country that does not allow private citizens to band together in a lawsuit for collective justice.[31] If that were the case, residents of Legacy at Imperial Village and Park’s Edge would have been able to confront their landlord in court without the financial or emotional burden of an independent suit. Even though both then-Governor Glenn Youngkin and current Governor Abigail Spanberger vetoed bills that would allow class-action lawsuits in Virginia, the fact that such bills have made it that far is hopeful.[32]
Another much needed change to the VRLTA is to expand the damages and remedies available to tenants such as allowing personal injury damages in tort. One renter at Park’s Edge in Charlottesville lost thousands of dollars because of the landlord’s negligence through things such as lost and damaged personal belongings and medical bills incurred as a result of living with unaddressed health and safety hazards.[33] While many of the damages vulnerable renters incur are largely tangible and can be calculated, neglectful landlords are almost never held accountable for the full extent of damage they caused. What often remains invisible is the emotional and mental toll that living in poor conditions can cause and the impact of these stressors such as even more financial challenges resulting from lost wages, increased health issues, and more.[34] A more just Virginia would expand the VRLTA so that residents can be properly compensated for the distress and indignity that neglectful landlords cause.
Safe and healthy living conditions should be accessible to every person regardless of income, and Virginia law should reflect that. While some progress has been made to expand protections for vulnerable renters, Virginia law still leaves low-income renters with little practical recourse when faced with neglectful landlords. Much more can be done to give low-income renters the same access to justice and proper living conditions that those with higher incomes are afforded, such as allowing class action lawsuits and expanding the remedies and damages provided to tenants through the VRLTA. Thus, the next step to properly holding neglectful landlords accountable is to hold our elected representatives accountable and demand more protections for our most vulnerable neighbors.
[1] See Tyler Lane, ‘It breaks my heart’: Richmond seniors struggle with bedbugs, broken elevators at apartment complex, CBS 6 News WTVR Richmond (Jun. 9, 2026), https://www.wtvr.com/news/local-news/richmond/legacy-at-imperial-village-june-9-2026.
[2] See id.
[3] See id.
[4] See id.
[5] See id.
[6] See Statement from City of Richmond Mayor Danny Avula, on Legacy at Imperial Village Conditions and Well-Being of Residents (July 1, 2026) (on file with author); Tyler Lane, Memo: Most urgent violations at Imperial Village fixed, but ‘long path ahead’ to full compliance, CBS 6 News WTVR Richmond (Aug. 5, 2026), https://www.wtvr.com/news/local-news/richmond/imperial-village-memo-august-5-2026.
[7] See Tyler Lane, ‘It breaks my heart’: Richmond seniors struggle with bedbugs, broken elevators at apartment complex, CBS 6 News WTVR Richmond (Jun. 9, 2026), https://www.wtvr.com/news/local-news/richmond/legacy-at-imperial-village-june-9-2026.
[8] See Erin O’Hare, In Albemarle County, Park’s Edge residents endure stinking floods, rat infestations, fire hazards — and a frequently unresponsive landlord, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 1, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/in-albemarle-county-parks-edge-residents-endure-stinking-floods-rat-infestations-fire-hazards-and-a-frequently-unresponsive-landlord/.
[9] See id.
[10] See Irene Lew, Housing Inadequacy Remains a Problem for the Lowest-Income Renters, Harvard University Joint Center for Housing Studies (May 19, 2016), https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/housing-inadequacy-remains-a-problem-for-the-lowest-income-renters.
[11] See id.
[12] See Va Code § 55.1-1220 (2026).
[13] See Erin O’Hare, Virginia law does not make it easy for a renter to force a landlord to improve conditions — even hazardous ones, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 3, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/virginia-law-does-not-make-it-easy-for-a-renter-to-force-a-landlord-to-improve-conditions-even-hazardous-ones/.
[14] See Va Code § 55.1-1220 (2026).
[15] See Va Code § 55.1-1234 (2026).
[16] See Va Code § 55.1-1244 (2026).
[17] See Va Code § 55.1-1244.1 (2026).
[18] See Virginia 2026 State Housing Report, National Low Income Housing Coalition (July 2026), https://nlihc.org/gap/state/va.
[19] See id.
[20] See Erin O’Hare, No way out: How Virginia law fails vulnerable renters, Charlottesville Tomorrow (May 29, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/no-way-out-how-virginia-law-fails-vulnerable-renters/; Erin O’Hare, Virginia law does not make it easy for a renter to force a landlord to improve conditions — even hazardous ones, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 3, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/virginia-law-does-not-make-it-easy-for-a-renter-to-force-a-landlord-to-improve-conditions-even-hazardous-ones/.
[21] See id.
[22] See Isbell v. Com. Inv. Assocs., Inc., 644 S.E.2d 72, 78 (2007).
[23] See Erin O’Hare, While state laws do little to protect tenants, counties have options — and Albemarle is beginning to consider them, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 4, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/while-state-laws-do-little-to-protect-tenants-counties-have-options-and-albemarle-is-beginning-to-consider-them/.
[24] See id.
[25] See id.
[26] See id.
[27] See Va Code § 55.1-1259 (2026); Erin O’Hare, While state laws do little to protect tenants, counties have options — and Albemarle is beginning to consider them, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 4, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/while-state-laws-do-little-to-protect-tenants-counties-have-options-and-albemarle-is-beginning-to-consider-them/.
[28] See id.
[29] See Va Code § 55.1-1241 (2026); Erin O’Hare, While state laws do little to protect tenants, counties have options — and Albemarle is beginning to consider them, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 4, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/while-state-laws-do-little-to-protect-tenants-counties-have-options-and-albemarle-is-beginning-to-consider-them/.
[30] See Va Code § 55.1-1241 (2026).
[31] See Erin O’Hare, No way out: How Virginia law fails vulnerable renters, Charlottesville Tomorrow (May 29, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/no-way-out-how-virginia-law-fails-vulnerable-renters/.
[32] See id; H.B. 418, 2024 Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. (Va. 2024); S.B. 229, 2026 Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. (Va. 2026).
[33] See Erin O’Hare, Virginia law does not make it easy for a renter to force a landlord to improve conditions — even hazardous ones, Charlottesville Tomorrow (June 3, 2026), https://www.cvilletomorrow.org/virginia-law-does-not-make-it-easy-for-a-renter-to-force-a-landlord-to-improve-conditions-even-hazardous-ones/.
[34] See Irene Lew, Housing Inadequacy Remains a Problem for the Lowest-Income Renters, Harvard University Joint Center for Housing Studies (May 19, 2016).