How a One-Hour Time Allotment Can Change the Lives of Domestic Victims

 

Kimberly Alves, Hourglass on Books (2016), https://www.pexels.com/photo/hourglass-on-books-in-an-office-setting-37494738/

By: Brandy Barnes

The gift of never experiencing domestic violence is something all people should experience. Unfortunately, 16,856 people called the Virginia Hotline for Domestic and Sexual Violence between January and March of 2026.[1] Another 18,051 individuals called between April and June 2026.[2] Between July and September of 2026: 17,385 calls.[3] Overall, 52,292 calls occurred from January 2026 to September 2026.[4] Those who call may unfortunately experience inappropriate questions about why they did not leave their abuser or why they failed to take legal action.[5] One of the common responses survivors give when they are asked this question is that the reason they are unable to leave is their inability to retrieve items or the inability to take their pets with them.[6] There are other reasons, and while this is a loaded question, there are certain measures we can take to respond to those critiques.[7] This article specifically addresses the lack of immediate protection available to domestic survivors to retrieve their things and depart.[8]

As stated, domestic violence is a complex situation, and it has been known to alter the brain in severely damaging ways.[9] A common way to view this change is “survival mode.”[10] When this occurs, the body reacts quickly, without “conscious thought.”[11] There are three common responses to this state of mind: fight, flight, and freeze.[12] This post will analyze flight mode, which occurs when the victim leaves or attempts to leave the environment.[13]

When a survivor is deciding whether to leave, fear of anticipated consequences may prevent them from leaving. If they do leave, challenges they did not anticipate can lead them back to their abuser.

Known consequences can be obvious, such as lack of financial stability and time invested in the relationship.[14] Other consequences may not be so obvious. For example, one study found that “more than a quarter of domestic violence victims stay in abusive relationships for a median time of two years to avoid leaving their pets behind.”[15] Additionally, an alarming rate of domestic violence victims return to their abusive partner because of concern for their pets’ safety.[16] This link between domestic violence and animal cruelty is significant, and it is often the reason animal owners return to their abuser or delay their exit.[17] Having nowhere to take the animal, or an emergency shelter not being able to accommodate a pet, is a separate issue.[18] The immediate, looming issue in Virginia is that no law exists to help survivors get their things, or animals, outside of a protective order.[19]  Even so, with a protective order, the animal may only be given to the owner, and the procedure for proving that is unclear.[20] While a protective order for no contact or other options can be speedy, that is not the case for the opportunity of being able to retrieve your items.[21] After the severance of a relationship, the court of law is the main avenue to retrieving items and getting back what was yours.

In addition to animals, if the domestic victim obtains a no-contact order, items that the victim could try to retrieve, such as their medication, their wallet, a car seat, work identification, and more, become hard to get, because a no-contact order means no contact.[22] An option to circumvent this is to file a Warrant in Detinue.[23] A Warrant in Detinue is a civil action used in Virginia to retrieve property that is unlawfully held by another person or business.[24] With this, the value of the items may be paid to the victim, but if the original items are destroyed, there is obviously no way to bring them back.

Therefore, one of the only speedy, viable options left, aside from awaiting a court date, is to contact the police to arrange a civil standby.[25] However, this is not always available, and in some jurisdictions, how much time you get to collect your things is up to the officer’s discretion. In the war of abuse, just when the survivor decides that they want to leave and calls an officer, they can be met with the harsh reality of being denied adequate time to retrieve their things. Currently in Virginia, there are no protections for people without a court order, and the police will only assist at their discretion. It is important to note that this discretion concerning civil standbys is not readily available in Virginia’s police guides and manuals. However, we can see an example of this variability by comparing Virginia to a different state: Washington’s Olympia Police Department’s Operations Manual.[26] This manual categorizes the process of retrieving things with a court order as a “standby request.”[27] During this standby request, the items are already limited to items that are not in dispute.[28] Even with this, the Olympia Police Department only allows “approximately fifteen minutes.”[29] Furthermore, if the additional party is uncooperative, the police will instruct the person requesting the standby to obtain legal advice.[30] Additionally, if the other party is not present, the officer will not allow the person requesting the standby entry.[31] There are obvious flaws to this method. The victim of the domestic dispute, without a full write-up of what is theirs in court, is left at the hands of the abuser once again.[32] We are relying on the abuser to be present at the location, and we are relying on the abuser to be cooperative with this standby.[33]

With this, there is a possible solution that Virginia should investigate: an act that would allow people fleeing dangerous situations up to one hour to collect their uncontested belongings, regardless of whether the other party is cooperative or present at the scene. As stated, in Virginia, there is currently no law that guarantees that in the split-second decision that a survivor decides to leave, a police officer will be there to help them get their things. It is based solely on the officer’s discretion, and survivors must only hope that the officer is having a good day. Otherwise, survivors could get an immensely restricted 15 minutes, as seen in a different state.[34] The act could cover uncontested belongings such as clothes, medication, items for children, furniture with proof of ownership, old photos, keepsakes, uncontested pets, or pets with proof of ownership readily available, and other important documents. Without this guaranteed immediate protection, Virginia is deterring victims from leaving their abuser; survivors can wait on a protective order or other court remedy, but by then their personal belongings could be destroyed, medication could be discarded, or pets could be harmed. With this preventative act, Virginia can support survivors leaving their abusers and lower the rates at which they stay or return.

 

 

[1] Virginia Data and Statistics Domestic Violence and Sexual Violence Data, Va. Sexual and Domestic Violence Action All., (April 9, 2026), https://vsdvalliance.org/statistics-and-data/

[2] Id.

[3] Id.

[4] Id.

[5] Pam Payne, Why is it so difficult for survivors to leave abusive relationships?, University of Nevada: Nevada today (Oct. 7, 2025).

[6]  Pet-Friendly Housing and Survivors of Domestic Violence, ASPCA, https://www.aspca.org/improving-laws-animals/public-policy/housing/pet-friendly-housing-and-survivors-domestic-violence (last visited June 4, 2026).

[7] Pam Payne, Why is it so difficult for survivors to leave abusive relationships?, University of Nevada: Nevada today (Oct. 7, 2025).

[8] Id.

[9] See Fight, Flight, of Freeze: Understanding Survivor Responses to Domestic Violence, Nationwide Children’s Hosp. (Oct. 4, 2024), https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/family-resources-education/700childrens/2024/10/fight-flight-or-freeze-understanding-survivor-responses-to-domestic-violence.

[10] Id.

[11] Id.

[12] Id.

[13] Id.

[14]  Pam Payne, Why is it so difficult for survivors to leave abusive relationships?, University of Nevada: Nevada today (Oct. 7, 2025).

[15] Pet-Friendly Housing and Survivors of Domestic Violence, ASPCA, https://www.aspca.org/improving-laws-animals/public-policy/housing/pet-friendly-housing-and-survivors-domestic-violence (last visited June 4, 2026).

[16] Id.

[17] Id.

[18] Id.

[19] See Protective Orders in Virginia, Va. Sexual and Domestic Violence Action All., https://vsdvalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Protective-Orders-in-Virginia-rev2022b.pdf (last visited June 4, 2026).

[20] Id.

[21] Id.

[22] See John J. Irving, Getting Your Belongings After A No-Contact Order in Va, Irving Law Firm, https://www.theirvinglawfirm.com/blog/getting-your-belongings-after-no-contact-order-va/ (last visited June 4, 2026).

[23] Va Code § 8.01-114.

[24] Id.

[25] Id.

[26] Olympia Police Department, Policy 431, Operations policy manual (Sept. 11, 2023).

[27] Id.

[28] Id.

[29] Id.

[30] Id.

[31] Id.

[32] Id.

[33] Id.

[34] Id.