Can We Trust Children’s Eyewitness Memory?

Gustavo Fring, A young girl and a counselor having a therapy session indoors, fostering emotional support (Photography, 2021), https://www.pexels.com/photo/man-in-black-blazer-talking-to-a-child-7447264/.

By: Brooke Powell

Think about your favorite childhood memory. Where were you? What did you see? What did you do that made it so special? Who were you with? How confident are you that your memory of the event is completely accurate?

It is easy to think of the human memory as a video recording. Eyes capture events and our brains store them exactly as they happen to be recalled at a later time. However, the reality of memory is far different from a direct recording saved on an iPhone; it is far more fallible.

Memories are shaped by what the viewer is paying attention to, the viewer’s expectations, her emotional state, and her memories already stored.[1] This information is encoded and then integrated with memories already stored. When retrieved, it is reconstructed from what remains in the brain including influences from subsequently experienced events and excluding forgotten details.[2] False memories, where someone remembers something that did not happen or happened differently than in reality, can emerge when the encoding process leaves out original details, when another person makes suggestions causing modification to the memory, or when an entirely new memory is created spontaneously.[3]

The phenomenon of false memory is particularly important when considering children’s eyewitness memory. Research indicates that children as young as two and a half years old are capable of recalling events with high levels of accuracy.[4] Children can recall negative or highly stressful events with accuracy..[5] However, children’s memories are also highly suggestible, which means that they can be influenced by a variety of internal or external factors, including interview questions asking for a yes or no answer, leading or misleading questions, question repetition, repeated interviews, reasonable suggestions, stereotyping, and peer conformity.[6] These factors can lead to false memories, which could have disastrous consequences when children present eyewitness testimony in legal proceedings.

Leading questions are a tactic commonly used in interviews but are also highly suggestible. [7] A leading question is one where the questioner suggests a certain version of events and presupposes the answer.[8] For example, “The defendant came over and touched you here, right?” A question like this presents a certain version of events and would require a child to correct the interviewer if that version of events was incorrect, which can be more difficult than simply agreeing.[9] Additionally, children generally trust that adults are telling the truth, so it can be even harder for a child to present a different version of an event when a seemingly trustworthy adult is saying something different.[10]

To avoid influencing answers, interviewers must use proper interview techniques when questioning children. There are numerous cases in which children provided key eyewitness testimony in court, but their memories were false or otherwise tainted from interview techniques.[11] In the well-known McMartin Preschool case, seven teachers at a preschool were accused of wide range of abuses, including child sexual abuse, satanic ritual abuse, kidnapping, and forcing children to watch tortured animals.[12] However, the court found that the manner in which the children were interviewed was highly improper, and these investigative interviews were the only evidence supporting these charges.[13] After a few years of investigation, all charges were dropped against five of the teachers without going to trial.[14] However, the remaining two went to trial, which spanned almost three years.[15] They were found not guilty on 52 counts, but the jury deadlocked on twelve molestation charges and one conspiracy charge.[16] The judge dismissed the conspiracy charge, and the prosecutors tried one defendant again on eight of the remaining counts, resulting in another deadlocked jury.[17] Afterwards, that defendant was not tried again and all charges were dropped.[18] Ultimately, this trial was, and currently is, the longest and most expensive criminal trial in United States history, spanning seven years and costing over fifteen million dollars.[19]

Similarly in State v. Michaels, a nursery teacher was convicted of sexually abusing several children after a child told his mother and nurse about the teacher’s inappropriate conduct..[20] The investigators conducted extensive interviews with the children at the nursery, but used leading questions, repeated questions, and suggestive techniques.[21] Consequently, the court found that these interviews were highly coercive, suggestive, and likely distorted the children’s memories of the events. Ultimately, these deficiencies undermined the reliability of those memories as sufficient evidence to support a conviction.[22]

In State v. Sargent, a man was charged with sexually assaulting three children with the primary evidence being the children’s eyewitness testimony.[23] After looking at the interview transcripts, the court determined that improper, suggestive interview tactics were used and admitted expert testimony on the danger of false memory implantation due to improper questioning.[24] In a later case, Jenkins v. Commonwealth, a community program volunteer was indicted for sexual abuse of children, but the court found that there was no evidence of this other than allegations that arose after a detective conducted highly suggestive and coercive interviews.[25]

These cases stress the importance of handling children’s memories with care and the danger that employing improper interview techniques can pose to the creation of false memories and presentation of false evidence. As an expert witness stated in State v. Larr, research indicates that 25-35 percent of allegations in child sexual abuse cases are false, and improper interview techniques strongly contribute to these unreliable and false memories.[26] The expert noted that proper interview techniques include the interviewer remaining neutral, asking open-ended questions, allowing the child to provide their own answers, and avoiding suggestive questions.[27] An interviewer should build rapport with the child, avoid interrupting the child, and conduct the interview in a safe location.[28] Each of these techniques help the interviewer to avoid tainting sensitive memories and elicit the most accurate recollections.[29]

Proper interview techniques are one of the ways participants in legal proceedings can protect children and seek the ultimate truth of a matter. Experts who have spent sufficient time with the child prior to testifying can also explain whether they believe the child’s testimony is reliable. This opinion should be based on their expert knowledge of child psychology, suggestibility, child development, and firsthand experience with the child.[30] This could help the factfinder make an informed decision about how much weight to give the child’s testimony and whether the child is telling the truth as it actually happened.[31]

Research in this area continues to expand and remains especially relevant in cases involving children. Above all, it is important to know that memory is not like an infallible video recording. A variety of factors, including simply the way a question is asked in an interview, may alter the integrity of memories, particularly in more suggestible populations like children. The best way to promote justice, protect children, and guard against wrongful convictions is to use proper interview techniques and understand that memories are not always accurate.

References:

[1] Mark L. Howe & Lauren M. Knott, The Fallibility of Memory in Judicial Processes: Lessons from the Past and Their Modern Consequences, 23 Memory 633 (2015).

[2] Id. at 634.

[3] See id.

[4] See, e.g., Robyn Fivush, Children’s Recollections of Traumatic and Nontraumatic Events, 10 Dev. & Psychopathology 699 (1998); Robyn Fivush et al., Content and Consistency in Young Children’s Autobiographical Recall, 14 Discourse Processes 373 (1991).

[5] See Ingrid M. Cordon, et al., Memory for Traumatic Experiences in Early Childhood, 24 Developmental Rev. 101, 122 (2004).

[6] Livia L. Gilstrap et al., Child Witnesses: Common Ground and Controversies in the Scientific Community, 32 Wm. Mitchell L. Rev. 59, 68 (2005).

[7] Daniel L. Schacter et al., True and False Memories in Children and Adults: A Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective, 1 Psych., Pub. Pol’y, & L. 411, 411 (1995).

[8] Avery Garrett, Comment, Two Truths and a Lie: A Proposal to Suppress the Risks of Child Testimony, 57 St. Mary’s L. J. 125, 128 (2025).

[9] Id.

[10] Id.

[11] See, e.g., Howe & Knott, supra note 1, at 636; State v. Michaels, 136 N.J. 299, 304-05 (1994); State v. Sargent, 144 N.H. 103 (1999); Jenkins v. Commonwealth, 308 S.W.3d 704, 714 (Ky. 2010); State v. Larr, No. CT2022-0069, 2023 WL 4199425, at *2 (Ohio Ct. App. 2023) (not reported in N.E.3d).

[12] Howe & Knott, supra note 1, at 636.

[13]  Id.

[14]  Id.

[15] Id.

[16] Sara Kettler, The McMartin Preschool Case: Satanic Panic and Child Sexual Abuse Allegations, A&E (Jan. 28, 2022).

[17] Id.

[18] Id.

[19] Id.

[20] State v. Michaels, 136 N.J. 299, 304-05 (1994).

[21] Id. at 313.

[22] Id. at 315.

[23] State v. Sargent, 144 N.H. 103 (1999).

[24] Id. at 104.

[25] Jenkins v. Commonwealth, 308 S.W.3d 704, 714 (Ky. 2010).

[26] State v. Larr, No. CT2022-0069, 2023 WL 4199425, at *2 (Ohio Ct. App. 2023) (not reported in N.E.3d).

[27] Id.

[28] Id.

[29] Id.

[30] Id. at 149.

[31] Id.